Seeking the internal melody of the heart

Nafs is not a static entity. It is our inner landscape and may evolve through different stages of consciousness if we keep our heart and mind in awareness. When an individual’s mind and heart are anchored in divine consciousness, then the nafs can journey from a space of our most base instincts to a state of ultimate spiritual peace.

The most primitive and unrefined state is the Nafs al-Ammarah, which may be translated as the dictating self. Herein, the mind is considered to be in a dictating or commanding state because it makes the individual operate purely on the pleasure principle and immediate gratification. Those in this space find themselves dictated by the belief, “If it feels good, do it.”

In such a state of mind, the nafs actively drives a person toward negative behaviour patterns without any sense of remorse. When an individual is in this space, he is governed entirely by raw instincts, ego (kibr), physical desires, and worldly passions. The total absence of moral self-awareness or regret makes this the base state of mind.

In Sufi poetry, the unrefined nafs is rarely described politely. It is often likened to a thief, trickster, stubborn donkey or wild dog that must be tamed. The great master Hazrat Abu Sa’id Abi’l-Khayr once spoke to his disciples about the subtle deception of this base self. He noted that a man might conquer an army and yet remain an absolute slave to his own ego. He shared this insight with his disciples: “The nafs is like a thief who sneaks into your house in the dark. If you fall asleep, he robs you of your most precious jewels—your awareness and your peace. But if you simply light a candle, the thief cannot operate; he either hides or flees. Awareness is that candle.”

The next stage is of Nafs al-Lawwamah or the self-accusing soul, which marks the awakening of conscience of an individual. From a mindset of “If it feels good, do it,” an individual evolves to a thought process where he starts questioning acts of mindless self-indulgence. At this stage, the individual is caught in a tug-of-war between his higher spiritual aspirations and his lower desires.

Hazrat Ibrahim ibn Adham (718–778), the 8th-century ruler of Balkh (modern-day Afghanistan) who gave up his royal throne to embrace a life of absolute poverty and asceticism, was asked once how he knew his soul had awakened to this self-accusing stage. He replied:

“Whenever I inclined toward comfort, a voice within me shattered the illusion. I once sat upon a soft cushion and felt a moment of deep satisfaction. Immediately, my inner conscience struck me, saying: ‘O Ibrahim, you were created for a long journey, yet you are falling asleep at the very first tavern.’ The true sign of this stage is that your own soul becomes a mirror that refuses to flatter you.”

When an individual is at the stage of Nafs al-Lawwamah, his evolving consciousness stirs him into watchfulness of himself when his mind slips up or gives in to temptation. He tends to regret mindless behaviour and reproaches himself, driving him to seek forgiveness (tawbah) from the Divine Almighty. This is a stage of self-reflection and marks the beginning of spiritual growth. It is an uncomfortable but essential transitional state.

The great Sufi poet Amir Khusrau (1253-1325) masterfully captured the agonizing, beautiful friction of Nafs al-Lawwamah – the heart that is deeply aware of its flaws, caught between worldly distraction and divine longing.

I know not what internal melody is playing inside my heart,

That though I am silent, my soul is consumed by cries.

Every vein in my body has become a taut string—

Whenever the breath of Love touches it, a lament breaks forth.

From a stage of intense watchfulness and constant questioning, the earnest seeker on the path of the Divine Beloved may transition to the stage of Nafs al-Mutma’innah.This is the ultimate stage of spiritual integration and tranquility, wherein inner conflict dissolves. Such a stage is reached with the blessings and grace of the Divine, where the mind is engaged in dhikr, viz. loving and constant remembrance of the Almighty. In this blessed state, the soul is able to align its own will with divine reality, finding total contentment, peace, and certainty. It is no longer swayed by the illusions of the ego or shaken by the trials of the material world.

The Persian mystic Hazrat Bayazid Bastami (804-874), also referred to as the Sultan-ul-Arifin (King of Those Who Know) was once asked, “When does a person know they have reached ultimate peace (itminan)?”

Hazrat Bayazid replied:

“When the heart becomes like the ocean: it does not change its taste whether you pour sugar or poison into it. I spent thirty years fighting my lower self, pulling it like a stubborn beast. But when I reached this clearing, I looked down and saw that the beast had transformed into a loyal companion. The conflict was gone, because there was no longer a ‘me’ left to fight.”

At the stage of Nafs al-Mutma’innah, the blessed seeker achieves the mindset of complete surrender, stillness, and divine satisfaction. With the soul anchored in tranquility (itminan), the mind is able to find liberation from anxiety, fear, and pulling desires. The heart is so anchored in divine reality that nothing in the material world can move it.

Hazrat Abu Sa’id Abi’l-Khayr frequently wrote about the absolute erasure of the self that leads to this perfect inner stillness, observing that when the ‘I’ is gone, only peace remains.

By day and night, I sought for peace in this world,

Yet found only the restless tossing of the mind’s dark sea

But when I stepped out of myself, and looked with open eyes

I saw that the Peace I sought was the very fabric of Reality.

These three stages highlight a seeker’s spiritual evolution.Nafs al-Ammarah is completely submerged in the ego; Nafs al-Lawwamah is actively fighting to swim to the surface; and Nafs al-Mutma’innah has finally broken through, breathing in absolute peace.

END OF ARTICLE